The San Francisco 49ers likely have a slight overstock of quarterbacks in 2019, which opens up a debate whether Nick Mullens or C.J. Beathard should be dealt in a trade at some point this year.
On the surface, it should be pretty easy to answer a question the San Francisco 49ers will likely face at some point in 2019.
The obvious answer would appear to be Mullens, who has shown he can effectively lead an understrength offense with average-to-good results already. And he was a big part of San Francisco’s three wins after Garoppolo suffered his season-ending ACL injury back in Week 3.
Beathard, on the other hand, has just one win to his credit in 10 starts spanning back to his rookie 2017 season. To date, his passer rating is 74.6 over his two-year career. Only two qualifying quarterbacks, the Buffalo Bills’ Josh Allen (67.9) and the Arizona Cardinals’ Josh Rosen (66.7) had lower passer ratings last year.
So the conclusion would be for the 49ers to move Beathard at some point in 2019, right? After all, the initial review suggests Mullens is the better option, and the fact head coach Kyle Shanahan kept the former undrafted free agent in the starting role over the latter half of 2018 is endorsement enough.
It’s highly unlikely either QB is dealt until after the 2019 preseason. But, assuming the Niners try to move one of their two backups, is it automatic Beathard winds up being the guy moved?
Let’s debate it out, shall we?